Start with a careful read
Read the editor decision and all reviewer reports once without editing. Note the deadline and whether the decision requests minor revision, major revision, or a new submission. Then read the comments again and group them by topic: methods, analysis, interpretation, presentation, and references.
Keep a separate list of required changes and questions. Some comments identify a real weakness; others ask for clarification or propose an alternative interpretation. You do not need to agree with every suggestion, but every concern deserves a considered answer.
- Save a copy of the submitted manuscript.
- Create a response document with one numbered entry per comment.
- Record which coauthor will handle each technical question.
Build a point by point response
Quote or summarize each reviewer comment, then reply directly underneath it. Thank the reviewer briefly, explain the action taken, and identify the location of the change using page, section, or line numbers from the revised manuscript. Make those references only after the manuscript is finalized.
When a suggestion is not adopted, state the reason calmly and support it with the study design, data, or scope. If the requested work is outside the paper’s scope, explain what the current study can and cannot establish. Avoid defensive language and avoid claiming a change that is not present in the file.
- Comment: “Please clarify how participants were selected.”
- Response: “We have added the inclusion criteria and recruitment period to Methods, section 2.1 (page 4).”
Make revisions easy to verify
Use track changes or the journal’s requested highlighting so editors can locate revisions. Keep a clean revised copy as well if requested. Check that the response letter and manuscript use the same terminology, section names, and page references.
A response may need additional analysis or a limitation statement. Do not add an analysis simply to satisfy a request if it is not methodologically sound. Discuss the issue with coauthors and explain a reasonable alternative when needed.
- Answer every numbered point, including minor copyediting requests.
- Check figures, tables, supplements, and references after revisions.
- Ask a coauthor who was not editing the response to check completeness.
Before resubmitting
Review the editor’s instructions, file naming rules, and submission checklist. Confirm that the revised manuscript, response letter, and any supplementary files are the correct versions. A clear response is respectful, specific, and verifiable: it tells the editor what changed and where to find it.
Frequently asked questions
Should I answer every reviewer comment?
Yes. Respond to each point, even when you disagree. Explain the reason and support it with evidence or the scope of the study.
Can I disagree with a reviewer?
Yes. Keep the reply respectful, explain your reasoning, and make any clarification needed in the manuscript.

